Ballymun Travelodge

Ballymun Travelodge



Not for the first time has the Celtic Sage modestly demonstrated his gift of prophecy! A couple of weeks ago I rounded off my review of Travelodge Dublin Airport (actually in Ballymun; see the review) by stating “In summary, nice building, poor management, woeful security, good value if you don’t get robbed.” I pointed out flaws with the security of the Car Park, and card controlled electronic security locks being out of order allowing access from the car park through the stairwell to all floors in the building.



http://daithaic.blogspot.com/2010/01/tale-of-two-travelodges.html



I also pointed out that the CCTV & “security guard” in the car park were not effective. Well today’s Irish Independent carries a report of a €1m robbery in the middle of the night where a gang broke into a room. €1m is equal to £901k or £751k if you buy a gift card at Marks and Spencer!



http://daithaic.blogspot.com/2010/01/its-not-fair-exchange-rate-its-rip-off.html



The paper reported a diamond dealer bravely tackled an armed gang as they robbed him of €1m worth of precious stones and jewellery as well as cash in his hotel bedroom early on the morning of the 29th January. Wholesale jeweller Noah Stefancki (64) was battered on the head with a hammer as he tackled one of the three raiders, but failed to prevent them taking his suitcase. Mr Stefancki told Gardai he had lost his life savings in the robbery of the jewels, which were not insured.





Gardai searching bins in one of the semi-derelict flat blocks behind the Travelodge



Russian-born Mr Stefancki, who lives and works in Southampton in England, is a regular visitor here and travels around the country for business deals with local jewellers. He booked a room in the Travelodge hotel in Ballymun after flying into Dublin Airport as he had stayed there previously and was known to some of the staff. Gardai believe he was the victim of opportunistic local criminals, who became aware that he was carrying a valuable haul in his suitcase, and kept watch on his movements until they established where he was staying. Officers suspect that the thugs did not anticipate such a major haul when they carried out the robbery. Publicity around the raid may now attract the attention of an organised crime gang boss, who could seek a slice of the proceeds.



Mr Stefancki was in his bedroom at around 12.15am when three masked raiders, armed with a gun and a hammer, forced their way in. He lunged at the closest member of the gang and attempted to stop him from grabbing the suitcase. But he was thumped twice on the head with the hammer and the gang escaped from the hotel on foot. They were pursued by Mr Stefancki on to Shangan Road but the three then turned into Coultry Road and escaped. There was no sign of any getaway car. Mr Stefancki immediately returned to the hotel and raised the alarm. After Gardai arrived at the scene, he was taken to the Mater Hospital for treatment for lacerations to his head. He was later discharged.





The insecure "security door" giving access to the Travelodge from the car park





The insecure underground car park



I had pointed out “However the big weakness is apparent when we came back that night and parked in the “secure” underground car park. We pressed the intercom at the car park entrance and without any conversation or checks we were let in. The car park is shared with apartment dwellers and retailers but there are plenty of clearly marked Travelodge spaces. You need to use your card key to access the hotel (and the lift and your room) but when we got to the “secure” doors they were “open” with the electronic lock disengaged so you could go straight in. Once in the lift lobby you could then access all the floors without a key by going up the stairwell. We spoke to the young receptionist the next morning she said the security lock was due to be repaired and had been out of action for weeks. She also said there was CCTV and there was a security guard in the car park. Well there may be CCTV but there is little point to it if there is nobody at reception to look at it. As for the “security guard” we saw what was happening when we were leaving the next day. There he was in an office in the car park chatting away to a friend and just opening the barrier without checking.”



Afterwards the hotel management commented on Trip Advisor;



“Management response from Lisa Walsh, Travelodge Group Revenue Manager

Jan 22, 2010

Hi there,

Thank you for taking the time to write your review. I would like to discuss these issues with you further as your comments disappoint us greatly.

I can assure you the under ground car park is secure – if the magnetic lock was off during the day it was for a maintenance purpose. It is always connected back up.

At this time I can only apologise for your bad experience & for any inconvenience caused.

Kindest Regards,

Lisa”



While proactive the main flaw in the response is that the security lock was not down during the day for maintenance but during the evening and according to the receptionist had been for weeks. It would be wrong to comment on a current criminal investigation but it will be interesting to see if the security flaws I pointed out were a factor in this robbery. As for Mr. Stefancki if I was a diamond dealer I would have stayed in a more central hotel with staff who had been there for ever like Buswells but I can see the attraction if he is travelling around of a hotel near the airport and the ring motorway around Dublin. It is not unusual as I found when I was with Irish revenue and called on manufacturing jewellers in Dublin for diamonds to be transported and dealt this way. Loose diamonds are kept in cloth rolls by grade and the value can be substantial. However if I was Noah Stefancki I would certainly be checking with my lawyer to see if any of the security defects the hotel was told about were a factor in this robbery?





One of the semi-derelict blocks of public housing behind Ballymun Travelodge